A cream that smelled exactly as it should a month ago now smells slightly different. Its colour has changed, the texture is thinner and a spot that was not there yesterday has appeared on the rim of the jar.
Is it microbiology? Maybe. But not necessarily.
Water separating from the oil phase can be the result of physical instability of the emulsion, darkening may be linked to oxidation or a chemical reaction of one of the ingredients, and a change in smell may come, for example, from the oxidation of oils or of the fragrance. A visible film or spot looks more like microbial contamination, but without microbiological testing the cause of the problem cannot be reliably determined.
The reverse is also true: a cosmetic product can look, smell and feel completely normal and yet no longer be microbiologically compliant.
That is exactly why, when formulating, it is not enough to deal only with composition, fragrance, texture and physical stability. Microbiological safety is an equal part of a well-designed formulation.
This article follows on from our topic of preservatives in cosmetics and takes it a step further. We will not only look at what to preserve a product with, but above all at why cosmetics spoil, what microorganisms need to grow and why the safety and shelf life of a product are never determined by a single preservative alone.
Why this concerns everyone who works with water
Bacteria, yeasts and moulds need a suitable environment to grow, and one of the basic conditions is enough available water.
That is why the microbiological risk of an emulsion, gel or toner differs fundamentally from the risk of a pure oil or an anhydrous balm.

If a formulation contains a water phase – for example water, hydrosol, aloe juice, an aqueous plant extract or another water-based ingredient – we have to address its microbiological stability.
However, this does not mean that it is enough to look at the percentage of water in the formulation. What matters to microorganisms is not only how much water the product contains, but how much of it is actually available to them.
And this brings us to one of the most important concepts in the microbiological stability of cosmetics.
Not all water is the same: what water activity aw is
Water activity – aw (water activity) – describes the amount of water in a system that is available for chemical and biological processes, including microbial growth. It is not the same as the percentage of water in the formulation.
Two products can contain a similar amount of water yet have different water activity and therefore a different microbiological risk.

Water activity is expressed as a value from 0 to 1. Pure water has an aw very close to 1. The lower the value, the less water is available to microorganisms.
Formally, aw is defined as the ratio of the water vapour pressure above the product to the water vapour pressure above pure water at the same temperature. For a formulator, however, the practical interpretation matters more: water may be present in a formulation, but not all of it is necessarily equally available to microorganisms.
What lowers water activity
Some dissolved substances bind water and reduce its availability. These include, for example:
- glycerine,
- some glycols and polyols,
- sugars,
- salts,
- some highly concentrated dissolved substances.
That is why, for example, a concentrated glycerine-based or very salty system can have a considerably lower aw than a conventional emulsion containing a similar proportion of water.
We know this principle very well from the food industry: jam can contain a considerable amount of water, but the high sugar concentration reduces its availability. Salt works in a similar way in heavily salted products.
In cosmetics, however, caution is needed. A few percent of glycerine in a moisturising cream will not turn it into a microbiologically stable product without preservation. Usual concentrations of humectants generally do not lower aw enough for a conventional water-based emulsion to be considered low-risk.
Lowering water activity is therefore one of the possible protective barriers, not a universal substitute for a preservative system.
Different microorganisms tolerate different aw
Microorganisms do not all have the same requirements either. In general, many bacteria need higher water activity, whereas some yeasts and moulds can grow even at lower aw values.
So lowering water activity can gradually limit the growth of individual groups of microorganisms, but there is no simple universal threshold below which every cosmetic product can automatically be labelled safe.
If low water activity is to form part of the expert microbiological justification for a product, aw should be measured on the finished product, not just estimated from the formulation. This can be of particular interest for products such as:
- concentrated glycerine gels,
- high-sugar formulations,
- salt scrubs,
- pastes,
- some low-water formulations,
- specific anhydrous products where the risk of water being introduced during use needs to be assessed.
Cosmetics are not protected by the preservative alone: the multi-barrier approach
When it comes to preserving cosmetics, the thinking is sometimes too simple: the product contains water → we add a preservative → done.
Professionally designed microbiological protection is more complex. It uses a principle we can call the multi-barrier approach – hurdle technology.
Instead of building the protection of the product solely on one preservative, we create several obstacles for microorganisms at once. Such barriers can include:
- a suitably chosen preservative system,
- the pH of the product,
- water activity,
- preservative boosters,
- chelating agents,
- hygienic manufacturing,
- a low initial microbial load of the raw materials,
- suitable packaging,
- the way the product is used,
- correct storage.
The individual barriers support one another. The aim is therefore not to use “the strongest possible preservative” or the highest possible amount of it. It is far more sensible to design the product so that the preservative system works under the most favourable conditions possible.
Preservative boosters: helpers that can do a lot
Alongside conventional preservatives, modern formulations often include preservative boosters.
These are substances whose main declared cosmetic function need not be preservation, but which can support the antimicrobial protection of the formulation and increase the efficacy of the entire preservative system.
They can work through different mechanisms. Some of them:
- disrupt the cell membranes of microorganisms,
- lower water activity,
- increase the sensitivity of microorganisms to preservatives,
- have a mild antimicrobial effect of their own,
- improve the conditions in which a conventional preservative can work more effectively.
In cosmetic formulations, we can come across the following substances in this role, for example:
- Ethylhexylglycerin,
- Caprylyl Glycol,
- Glyceryl Caprylate,
- 1,2-Hexanediol,
- Pentylene Glycol.
Their strength lies mainly in combination with other barriers. For example, Ethylhexylglycerin is often used together with Phenoxyethanol. On its own, it cannot simply be regarded as a substitute for a conventional broad-spectrum preservative system, but in combination it can improve its overall efficacy.
Similarly, Glyceryl Caprylate or Caprylyl Glycol can contribute to antimicrobial protection, but their real effect depends on the concentration, pH, type of emulsion and other ingredients in the formulation.
This is an important point: the presence of a booster does not automatically mean that we can reduce the amount of the conventional preservative. If we want to optimise the system or reduce the concentration of any of its parts, the functionality of the resulting combination has to be verified on the finished product.
Chelating agents: an inconspicuous but very useful barrier
Another group that often stays in the background when it comes to preservation is chelating agents. Chelating agents bind metal ions – for example iron, copper, calcium or magnesium – which get into the product from water, plant extracts, mineral raw materials, trace impurities in raw materials or from manufacturing equipment.
They are of interest to the formulator for two reasons. Metal ions can catalyse oxidation reactions – faster oxidation of oils, colour changes, degradation of sensitive active ingredients or the development of an unpleasant odour – so binding them improves the chemical stability of the formulation. At the same time, many microorganisms need metal ions for their enzymes and metabolic processes to work; chelation makes these ions unavailable to them and, in some Gram-negative bacteria, also affects the stability of the outer membrane and increases their sensitivity to other antimicrobial substances.
So a chelating agent is not a preservative and on its own will generally not solve the microbiological protection of a product. It is, however, another barrier that can make the preservative system more robust.
For formulations aiming at a more natural profile, you can reach for Sodium Phytate, for example; a gentle alternative is sodium gluconate, and a technologically powerful, biodegradable solution is Trilon M Max EcoBalanced. And once again: what matters is not the mere presence of a chelating agent, but its suitability for the specific formulation, the amount used and the pH. We look at choosing one in more detail in a separate article on chelating agents.
Where microorganisms in cosmetics come from
Microorganisms do not appear in a product by themselves. They have to get into it. From a practical point of view, we mainly distinguish between primary and secondary contamination.
Primary contamination: the problem arises during manufacturing
Sources can include:
- microbiologically contaminated raw materials,
- unsuitable water,
- insufficiently cleaned equipment,
- containers and tools,
- the working environment,
- dust,
- staff,
- incorrectly stored raw materials.

With plant powders, extracts and some natural raw materials, the natural microbial load can be considerably higher than with highly purified synthetic raw materials. This is another reason why a preservative cannot replace good manufacturing practice.
The job of a preservative system is not to disinfect a badly made product. It is meant to protect a correctly made product during storage and use. The higher the initial microbial load, the harder the task the preservative system faces.
Secondary contamination: microorganisms arrive with the user
The second problem arises while the product is being used. We scoop cream out of an open jar with our fingers. A body scrub sits in the shower and we use it with wet hands. Water, bathroom splashes or dirt from the skin can get into the packaging.

A serum sealed in airless packaging, where the user practically never comes into contact with the contents, is exposed to an entirely different risk.
That is why packaging is not just a matter of design or marketing. It is part of the microbiological design of the product. Airless bottles, pumps and packaging with a small dispensing opening can significantly reduce secondary contamination. A wide, open jar represents a higher risk.
Bacteria, yeasts and moulds: we do not have to see the contamination
Microbial contamination can cause:
- a change in smell,
- a change in colour,
- a change in viscosity,
- thinning of the product,
- cloudiness,
- gas formation,
- bloating of the packaging,
- a film on the surface,
- visible colonies or mould.
However, these signs do not allow us to say reliably whether we are dealing with bacteria, yeasts or moulds. Moreover, the same changes can also have a non-microbiological cause.
Separation of an emulsion can be a physical problem. Darkening can be oxidation. An unpleasant smell can result from the degradation of an oil. That is why the appearance of a product is not a microbiological test.
And this is particularly important: the absence of visible changes is not proof of microbiological purity. A product can be microbiologically non-compliant even before its appearance or smell changes.

If visible mould appears on a cosmetic product, however, it is not enough to remove the affected part. The whole product must be considered contaminated and should no longer be used.
pH matters more than it may seem
We do not adjust the pH of a cosmetic product only for the sake of the skin or the stability of active ingredients. It can also have a fundamental effect on the preservative system.
A typical example is preservative systems based on organic acids, for example benzoic or sorbic acid and their salts. Their antimicrobial efficacy depends on what proportion of the acid is in its undissociated form. This ratio changes with pH.
The result? The same concentration of a preservative can work very well at one pH and much less effectively at a higher pH.
That is why it is not enough to say: “I used 1% preservative.” The right questions are:
- Which preservative system?
- Which active substances does it contain?
- At what final concentration?
- At what pH?
- Is it effective at this pH?
- Is it compatible with the other ingredients in the formulation?
We measure pH on the finished product, and during development it is also useful to monitor how it changes during stability testing. Some formulations can shift slightly in pH over time.
How to add a preservative correctly
There is no universal technological procedure for all preservative systems. The technical documentation from the manufacturer of the specific preservative always takes precedence.
In practice, however, one very common rule applies: many modern preservative systems are added towards the end of production, once the product has cooled to below approximately 40–45 °C. This is a good general formulation principle, not a universal law.
Some preservatives or components of preservative blends are sensitive to high temperatures or prolonged heating, while other systems allow or require a different method of incorporation. That is why we always check:
- the recommended temperature of addition,
- the solubility of the preservative,
- the phase into which it should be incorporated,
- the recommended pH,
- the maximum permissible temperature exposure.
With pH-sensitive preservative systems, it is advantageous to add them to a formulation that is practically finished and whose approximate final pH we know. However, the final pH check is only carried out after the preservative and the other ingredients have been incorporated, because the preservative system itself can change the pH of the formulation.
Usage rate: less may not be enough, more may not be permitted
With preservatives, a very important rule applies: the supplier’s recommended usage rate and the legal limit are not the same thing.
The supplier of a commercial preservative system may, for example, recommend a usage rate of 0.5–1.0%. That is a recommendation for that specific blend. European legislation, however, sets maximum concentrations of individual preservatives in the finished cosmetic product.
In the EU, permitted preservatives and the conditions for their use are listed in Annex V to Regulation (EC) No 1223/2009 on cosmetic products. The Regulation also states that substances listed in this annex may be used as preservatives under the conditions laid down in it.
For example:
- Phenoxyethanol – maximum 1.0% in the finished product,
- Sorbic Acid and its permitted salts – maximum 0.6% expressed as acid,
- Salicylic Acid and its permitted salts when used as a preservative – maximum 0.5% expressed as acid, with further restrictions applying to certain product types and to use in children,
- Benzoic Acid and Sodium Benzoate – the limit depends on the product type: for rinse-off products except oral care products, 2.5% expressed as acid is given, for oral care products 1.7% and for leave-on products 0.5%.
For parabens, formaldehyde releasers and other regulated preservatives, specific limits and conditions of use are likewise laid down.
For the formulator, this has a very practical consequence. It is not enough to know: “This preservative is used at 1%.” We also need to know its INCI composition and the content of regulated preservatives, so that we know what amount of each substance will ultimately be present in the finished product.
The legal maximum is not a recommended usage rate for formulating, though. It is the highest permitted concentration under the specified conditions. And the reverse also applies: being below the maximum legal limit does not yet mean that the product is sufficiently preserved. The efficacy has to work in the specific formulation.
Why the same preservative does not work the same way in every cream
A preservative in a formulation does not exist in isolation. Its efficacy can be affected by:
- pH,
- water activity,
- solubility,
- the amount of oil phase,
- emulsifiers,
- surfactants,
- solubilisers,
- polymers and thickeners,
- electrolytes,
- proteins,
- plant extracts,
- other organic substances,
- packaging,
- the initial microbial load.
A very interesting example is the partitioning of a preservative between the oil phase and the water phase of an emulsion. Microorganisms need available water to grow, so we are interested in how much of the active preservative is actually available in the water phase.
If a substance has a high affinity for the oil phase or binds strongly into micelles formed by surfactants, its total concentration in the product may well be correct, but its effective availability where we need it may be lower.
That is also why there is no simple equation: 1% preservative = a safe cream.
Packaging is part of the formulation
An airless bottle, a pump, a narrow-neck bottle and an open jar do not represent the same microbiological risk. With an airless system, the user practically never touches the contents of the product. With a jar, every use can introduce into the product:
- microbial flora from the skin,
- moisture,
- water,
- dirt from the surroundings.
Using products in the bathroom or shower can be particularly risky. The choice of packaging can therefore influence how robust the whole preservative system needs to be. From a microbiological point of view, we therefore design the packaging together with the formulation, not after it is finished.
What about anhydrous products?
Oils, oil serums, anhydrous balms and many body butters generally have a low microbiological risk, because they do not provide microorganisms with enough available water to grow. However, this does not mean: no water = automatically no risk.
Imagine an anhydrous sugar or salt scrub in a wide jar sitting in the shower. The manufacturer filled it as an anhydrous product, but the consumer repeatedly reaches into it with wet hands and introduces small amounts of water. After a few uses, the microenvironment in part of the product may no longer be the same as when it was made.
When assessing the risk, we therefore look at:
- composition,
- water activity,
- packaging,
- method of application,
- the likelihood of contact with water,
- conditions of use.
An anhydrous product in a pump represents a different situation from an anhydrous scrub in an open jar in the shower.
Vitamin E is not a preservative
This is one of the most common misconceptions in homemade cosmetics. Tocopherol – vitamin E – is an antioxidant, not an antimicrobial preservative. Its main role is to slow down the oxidation of lipids.
So it can help to:
- delay the yellowing of oils,
- limit the development of oxidative odour,
- extend the oxidative stability of the oil phase.
However, it does not provide sufficient protection of a water-based product against bacteria, yeasts and moulds. Oxidative stability and microbiological stability are two different things. A product can be excellently protected against oxidation and still be microbiologically non-compliant – or the other way round.
How we find out whether a preservative system really works
We cannot tell for certain from the formulation. We can choose a suitable preservative, set the pH correctly, use a chelating agent, a booster and airless packaging – yet we are still working with an assumption until we verify the antimicrobial protection of the finished product.
This is what the preservation efficacy test, commonly known as the challenge test, is for. In the test, the finished product is inoculated in a controlled way with defined microorganisms, and the development of their numbers is then monitored over a set period.
The aim is not to prove that the cosmetic product is sterile. Cosmetics do not have to be sterile. The aim is to verify whether its antimicrobial protection system can sufficiently suppress the microbial load.
The reference standard is ISO 11930:2019 – Cosmetics — Microbiology — Evaluation of the antimicrobial protection of a cosmetic product. The standard covers both the preservation efficacy test and the procedure for evaluating the overall antimicrobial protection of the product. It also recognises that the conventional challenge test is not intended for low microbiological risk products whose risk has been determined as low on the basis of an appropriate assessment.
A third edition of ISO 11930 is being prepared in 2026, but it is still only a draft, and the current published standard remains ISO 11930:2019.
This is an important distinction. “Contains water” does not automatically mean “add 1% preservative”. And “contains no water” does not automatically mean “I do not need to worry about microbiology”. We always assess the specific product.
So how should a preservative system be designed?
Instead of asking: “What percentage of preservative should I add?” it is more useful to proceed systematically.
- What microbiological risk does the product represent? Does it contain a water phase? What water activity might it have? Does it contain many plant extracts or other microbiologically more demanding raw materials?
- What will its final pH be? Is it within the range in which the chosen preservative system works?
- Which preservative system suits the formulation? Is it suitable for a leave-on or a rinse-off product? Is it compatible with the emulsifiers, surfactants and other raw materials?
- Can we support the system with a preservative booster? Can a suitable multifunctional ingredient increase its robustness or complement its mechanism of action?
- Does a chelating agent make sense? Does the product contain plant extracts, mineral components or raw materials in which trace metals may be present? Will a chelating agent help with both chemical and microbiological stability?
- What packaging will we use? Airless packaging and an open jar create completely different conditions of use.
- How will the product be used? On dry skin? In the bath? In the shower with wet hands? Will it be used by one person or by several?
- How will we verify that the system really works? A theoretically well-designed formulation is not in itself proof of microbiological safety.
And this is precisely how preservation stops being a question of a single ingredient.
Frequently asked questions
Does every cream need a preservative?
A conventional emulsion with high water activity generally needs an effective preservative system. The specific method of protection, however, depends on the pH, water activity, composition, packaging and the way the finished product is used.
Does a hydrosol need a preservative?
A hydrosol is a water-based raw material and can become microbiologically contaminated. Distillation during its production does not mean that it will remain sterile throughout its entire life. You need to know its microbiological quality and how the supplier has preserved it, and then assess the finished formulation in which you use it.
Is vitamin E a preservative?
No. Tocopherol is an antioxidant. It helps protect lipid components against oxidation, but it does not replace an antimicrobial preservative system.
Can I use less preservative if I add a booster?
Possibly – but not automatically. A suitable combination of preservative, booster, chelating agent, pH and other barriers can be very effective. However, this does not mean that after adding a booster we can simply reduce the preservative to, say, half. The resulting antimicrobial protection has to be verified on the finished product.
Is a chelating agent a preservative?
No. A chelating agent binds metal ions and can support both the preservative system and the chemical stability of the formulation. It is an additional barrier, not a full substitute for a preservative.
Does an anhydrous scrub need a preservative?
Not always. What matters is the microbiological risk of the product and the way it is used. An anhydrous scrub in an open jar used with wet hands in the shower represents a different risk from an oil serum sealed in a pump bottle.
Is it enough to follow the preservative manufacturer’s recommended usage rate?
No. The recommended usage rate is a starting point. The preservative system must be suitable for the given pH and formulation, it must meet the legal requirements, and the resulting antimicrobial protection must be sufficient in the finished product.
How can I tell if a cosmetic product has gone off?
A change in smell, colour or texture, cloudiness, gas formation, bloating of the packaging or visible microbial growth are reasons to stop using the product. However, the absence of these signs is not proof of microbiological purity.
What to combine it with from the Handymade range
If you are making an emulsion, gel, toner, serum or other cosmetic product with a water phase, do not choose a preservative only on the basis of whether it is labelled “natural”.
Look at the whole system: pH, product composition, water activity, emulsion type, active ingredients used, recommended usage rate, method of incorporation and packaging.
In our range of preservatives you will find various systems suitable for different types of formulation. With each of them, we recommend working with the manufacturer’s technical documentation and respecting its recommended concentration, incorporation temperature and pH range.
When designing a more robust system, it is also worth looking at preservative boosters and chelating agents, which can support a suitably chosen preservative system.
If you do not yet know which preservative is right for your formulation, continue with our article on preservatives, where we discuss the individual types and their use in more detail.
Conclusion: the preservative is just one piece of the puzzle
The microbiological safety of cosmetics does not come about the moment we add a preservative to the formulation. It begins with the quality of the water and raw materials, continues with manufacturing hygiene and the design of the formulation itself, and ends with suitable packaging, the way the product is used and verification of the finished product.
pH + water activity + preservative system + preservative boosters + chelating agents + good manufacturing practice + suitable packaging + efficacy verification. That is the multi-barrier approach.
Each barrier works in a slightly different way, and it is precisely by combining them that we can create a robust product without relying on a single substance.
That is why the question: “Which preservative is the best?
Sources:
- Regulation (EC) No 1223/2009 of the European Parliament and of the Council on cosmetic products, Annex V — list of preservatives allowed (EUR-Lex)
- ISO 11930:2019 — Cosmetics — Microbiology — Evaluation of the antimicrobial protection of a cosmetic product
- ISO/DIS 11930 — forthcoming third edition of the standard (only a draft at the time of publication of this article)



